Saturday, May 10, 2025

1. 1898


Columbia Theatre, Brooklyn.

by

Samuel L. Leiter

This is one of several blogs I’ve created to record the progress of Brooklyn, New York’s, theatre history from January 1, 1898, the day that the City of Brooklyn became the Borough of Brooklyn, as part of Greater New York City. For a week-by-week verbal as well as pictorial summary of theatrical activity, see STAGES IN BROOKLYN’S PAST (for the first six weeks) and ANNALS OF THE BROOKLYN STAGE for everything afterward. The weekly “Amusements” page ads in each Sunday’s Brooklyn Eagle are pasted here so they can be viewed in aggregate without having to read the descriptive background. For as long as I’m able, I’ll continue to add to this blog, which, obviously, will move much faster into the future than the weekly summaries provided in ANNALS OF THE BROOKLYN STAGE.

Readers interested in a thorough history of Brooklyn theatre from its beginnings to December 31, 1897, should consult my book, BROOKLYN TAKES THE STAGE: NINETEENTH-CENTURY THEATER IN THE CITY OF CHURCHES (McFarland, 2024).

A week-by-week chronology of the shows listed for legitimate theatres precedes the Amusement pages. Note that one-act plays, often with famous stars, were often being done on vaudeville stages. Their titles and stars can be found in the ads, especially for Hyde & Behman’s, but they are not included in chronology since they were only part of long bills with multiple acts.

Note that by late April theatres begin closing for the season, and that, by July, both legit and nonlegit theatres are closed for the hot summer months. They slowly begin to reopen at the end of August. These openings and closings, as well theatres being shut down or opened for other reasons, are duly noted.

Midway through, on June 19, the theatrical season of 1897-1898 closed for good, with the only local offerings of professional theatrical entertainment being comic operas and the like at the open-air shore theatres of Bergen Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Brighton Beach. There was also a Floating Roof Garden that gave light entertainment aboard the steamer Republic in New York Bay, picking up passengers from several Brooklyn piers.

Note on summer theatres of Brooklyn south shore beach communities:

At the turn of the 20th century, the summer theaters at Bergen Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Brighton Beach in Brooklyn offered a mix of open-air and enclosed venues, reflecting the era's diverse entertainment preferences. Here's an overview of each:


Bergen Beach

Bergen Beach, developed in the 1890s by vaudeville impresario Percy G. Williams and chewing gum magnate Thomas Adams, featured a resort with various attractions, including a casino and the Trocadero Theatre. The term "casino" at the time referred to a venue for entertainment rather than gambling. These establishments hosted vaudeville, musical comedies, and stock company productions. While specific architectural details are scarce, it's likely that these venues were enclosed structures to accommodate performances and audiences comfortably.


Manhattan Beach

Manhattan Beach was renowned for its open-air entertainment. North of the dining pavilion stood a vast outdoor stadium where James Pain, an English fireworks manufacturer, presented pyrotechnic shows. These spectacles combined pageantry, drama, and fireworks, offering audiences a unique open-air theatrical experience.


Brighton Beach

Brighton Beach's theatrical scene evolved over time. Initially, it featured open-air venues, such as the Brighton Beach Music Hall, which hosted concerts and performances in an outdoor setting. By 1910, the New Brighton Theatre, an enclosed venue designed by Dodge & Morrison, was established. This theater became a notable spot for plays and performances, indicating a shift towards enclosed theatrical spaces in the area.

See the article reprinted below, located chronologically, from the Eagle of June 19, 1898, for an account of the just ended, 41-week 1897-98 season and a comment on what was now available for Brooklyn theatergoers.

CHRONOLOGY: 1898

1. January 3-January 8, 1898

Montauk: An American Citizen, with Nat. C. Goodwin and Maxine Elliott

Columbia: A Stranger in New York,

Amphion: Heartsease, with Henry Miller

Grand Opera House: A Ward of France, with Maurice Barrymore

Bijou: A Guilty Mother

Park (stock): Incog (evenings); Little Lord Fauntleroy (matinees)

Gayety: Who Is Who?, with Kelley and Mason

American: The Fast Mail

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

2.    January 10-15, 1898

Columbia: A Stranger in New York

Montauk: The Girl from Paris

Amphion: Cumberland ‘61

Grand Opera House: McSorley’s Twins

Bijou: Heart of the Klondike

Park (stock): The Lights o’ London

Gayety: Hyde’s Comedians

American: The Captain’s Mate

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

3.    January 17-22, 1898

American: Shannon of the Sixth

Bijou: In Old Kentucky

Montauk: The Girl from Paris

Columbia: The Circus Girl

Amphion: Never Again

Grand Opera House: Superba

Park (stock): The Lost Paradise

Gayety: The Pacific Mail

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

4.   January 24-January 29, 1898

American: The Midnight Flood

Bijou: The Great Train Robbery

Brooklyn Academy of Music: The Geisha

Columbia: The Circus Girl

Amphion: The Cat and the Cherub, with Anna Held

Gayety: Superba

Grand Opera House: Who Is Who?, with Kelly and Mason

Montauk: The Senator, with William H. Crane

Park (stock): The Streets of New York

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire,         Star

5.    January 31-February 5, 1898

American: The Dear Irish Home and The Cruiskeen Lawn

Montauk: The Countess Valeska, with Julia Marlowe

Columbia: The Idol’s Eye

Amphion: My Friend from India

Grand Opera House: The Pacific Mail

Bijou: The Electrician

Park (stock): The Ticket-of-Leave Man

Gayety: Vaudeville, with Vesta Tilley

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire,         Star

6.    February 7-February 12, 1898

American: The Land of the Living

Amphion: The Geisha

Bijou: Fallen Among Thieves

Columbia: A Marriage of Convenience, with John Drew

Gayety: The Governors, with Ward and Vokes

Grand Opera House: Primrose and West’s Minstrels

Montauk: Romeo and Juliet, For Bonnie Prince Charlie, As You Like It, Ingomar, with Julia Marlowe

Park (stock): The New Unknown

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire,         Star

7.    February 14-19, 1898

American: Ingomar, Leah the Forsaken, East Lynne, repertory with Rachelle Renard

Amphion: The Girl from Paris

Bijou: Cumberland ‘61

Columbia: Die Lachtaube, Waldmeister, La Belle Hélène, Die Fledermaus, in repertory with Conried Comic Opera Company

Gayety: Primrose and West’s Minstrels

Grand Opera House: In Gay New York

Montauk: A Bachelor’s Romance, with Sol Smith Russell

Park (stock): The Galley Slave (last week of Park Theatre Stock Company)

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

8.    February 21-26, 1898

Amphion: A Stranger in New York

Bijou: East Lynne

Columbia: Jack and the Beanstalk

Gayety: In Gay New York

Grand Opera House: A Hot Old Time, with Johnny and Emma Ray

Montauk: The Swell Miss Fitzwell, with May Irwin

Park: Kit, The Arkansas Traveler

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

9.    February 28-March 5, 1898

[American: No public program; 2 benefit performances of The Chain of Destiny for manager). Theatre closes, is auctioned off, and returns as the Novelty in November]

Amphion: The Idol’s Eye, with Frank Daniels

Bijou: At Gay Coney Island, with Mathews and Bulger

Columbia: The Heart of Maryland, with Mrs. Leslie Carter

Gayety: A Hot Old Time, with Johnny and Emma Ray

Grand Opera House, An Irish Gentleman, with Andrew Mack

Montauk: Secret Service, with William Gillette

Park: The Land of the Living, with Lillian Washburn

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

10.                       March 7-12, 1898

Amphion: Under the Red Robe

Bijou: Sweet Inniscarra, with Chauncey Olcott

Columbia: Never Again

Gayety; At Gay Coney Island

Grand Opera House: A Milk White Flag

Montauk: Secret Service, with William Gillette

Park: The Man in the Iron Mask

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

11.                       March 14-19, 1898

Amphion: The Wedding Day, with Lillian Russell, Della Fox, Jeff De Angelis

Bij ou: Uncle Tom’s Cabin

Columbia: The French Maid

Gayety: An Irish Gentleman, with Andrew Mack

Grand Opera House: The Prisoner of Zenda

Montauk: Secret Service, with William Gillette

Park: The Cruiskeen Lawn, with Dan McCarthy

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

12.                       March 21-March 26, 1898

Amphion: A Lady of Quality, with Julia Arthur

Bijou: Alone in London, with Cora Tanner

Columbia: The French Maid, with Saharet

Gayety: The Prisoner of Zenda

Grand Opera House: The Sporting Duchess

Montauk: The Moth and the Flame, with Effie Shannon and Herbert Kelcey

Park: A Bunch of Keys, with Ada Bothner

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

13.                       March 28-April 2, 1898

Amphion: Closed for season

Brooklyn Academy of Music: The Country Girl and Lilli Tse, The School for Scandal, The Taming of the Shrew, repertory with Ada Rehan

Bijou: “Hermann the Great,” magic show with Leon and Adelaide Hermann

Columbia: The Royal Box, with Charles Coghlan

Gayety: The Foundling, with Cissy Fitzgerald

Grand Opera House: The Sunshine of Paradise Alley

Montauk: The Telegraph Girl, with Louis Mann and Clara Lipman

Park: The Span of Life

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

14.                       April 4-April 9, 1898

Bijou: Northern Lights

Columbia: The Ballet Girl

Gayety: The Sunshine of Paradise Alley

Grand Opera House: Lucia di Lammermoor and Cavalleria Rusticana, Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: The Princess and the Butterfly, with Mary Mannering and James K. Hackett

Park: Waifs of New York, with Merry Katie Emmett

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

15.                       April 11-16, 1898

Bijou: McFadden’s Row of Flats

Brooklyn Academy of Music, The Country Girl, The School for Scandal, The Taming of the Shrew, with Ada Rehan

Columbia: The Ballet Girl

Gayety: Uncle Tom’s Cabin

Grand Opera House: Olivette, Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: The Wedding Day, with Lillian Russell, Della Fox, and Jeff De Angelis

Park: Out in the Streets, with N.S. Wood

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

16.                       April 18-23, 1898

Bijou: Hamlet, Othello, Julius Caesar, Romeo and Juliet, Spartacus, repertory with Louis James

Columbia: The Fair at Midgettown

Gayety: East Lynne, with Wilton Lackaye, Nance O’Neil

Grand Opera House: Il Trovatore (in English), Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: A Virginia Courtship, with William H. Crane

Park: A Romance of Coon Hollow

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

17.                       April 25-April 30, 1898

Bijou: The Two Orphans, with Kate Claxton

Columbia: Oh! Susanna! and “Dangerfield, 95,” with Annie Russell

Gayety: Maggie Cline and her vaudeville company

Grand Opera House: Il Trovatore, Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: El Capitan, with De Wolf Hopper

Park: Closed for the season

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

18.                       May 2-May 7, 1898

Bijou: Gettysburg

Columbia: Closed for the season

Gayety: The Cherry Pickers

Grand Opera House: The Mikado, Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: Lord Chumley; The Lady of Lyons, with E.H. Sothern and Virginia Harned

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

19.                       May 9-14, 1898

Bijou: White Squadron, with Robert Hilliard

Gayety: New Eight Bells

Grand Opera House: Fra Diavolo, Jaxon Opera Company

Montauk: One Summer’s Day, with John Drew

Vaudeville and burlesque: Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire

20.                       May 16-21, 1898

Bijou: Othello, As You Like It, Richard III, Julius Caesar, with Even Plimpton and Mary Shaw

Gayety: Closed for the season

Grand Opera House: H.M.S. Pinafore, Cavalleria Rusticana, Maritana, Jaxon Opera House

Montauk: Closed for the season

Vaudeville and burlesque: Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire Theatre, Star Theatre

21.                       May 23-May 28, 1898

Bijou: Eight Bells

Grand Opera House: Closed for the season

Vaudeville and burlesque: Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire Theatre, Star Theatre

22.                       May 30-June 4

Bijou: Vaudeville

23.                       June 6-June 11, 1898

Bijou: Closed for the season

Montauk: Castle Hall Opera Company

Vaudeville and burlesque: Brooklyn Music Hall closed for the season.

The Castle Hall Opera Company occupied the Montauk for several weeks in June but, without air conditioning, all other Brooklyn theatres were closed, except for those that provided several comic operas in outdoor venues near the shore in Bergen Beach, Manhattan Beach, and Brighton Beach; Coney Island wasn’t interested in this kind of entertainment. We will skip them here. An idea of their offerings can be seen in these ads. Most shows were musical, but a small number of light comedies also were presented. By the first week of July, all Manhattan theatres except the Casino also had closed for the summer, replaced by several roof garden theatres in the warm, open air.

By the time the ad below appeared on August 28, Manhattan and Brooklyn’s theatres were slowly revving up for their fall openings.

24.                       August 29-September 3, 1898

Montauk: What Happened to Jones (opened August 29)

Park (stock returns): How Brown Was Hypnotized (opened Saturday night, August 27)

Vaudeville and burlesque: Star, Brooklyn Music Hall reopen. Shows still being done in Bergen Beach and Manhattan Beach, and on a Floating Roof Garden that sailed on the steamer Grand Republic through New York waters among the fleet.

25.                       September 3-September 12, 1898

Bijou: The Dawn of Freedom, with Ethel Barrymore (opened September 3)

Gayety: An Enemy to the King (opened September 3)

Grand Opera House: A Sure Cure (opened September 5)

Montauk: A Stranger in New York

Park (stock): The Open Gate and The New Private Secretary

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

26.                       September 14-19, 1898

Bijou: The Grip of Steel

Gayety: A Sure Cure

Grand Opera House: My Friend from India

Montauk: The Belle of New York, with Dan Daly

Park (stock): Our Boarding House

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

27.                       September 19-24, 1898

Amphion: The Telegraph Girl

Bijou: Two Little Vagrants

Gayety: My Friend from India

Grand Opera House: At Piney Ridge

Montauk: The White Heather

Park (stock): Saints and Sinners, J.H. Stoddart

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

28.                       September 26-October 1, 1898

Amphion: Diplomacy, with Mary Shaw

Bijou: Going to the Races

Columbia: The Meddler, with Stuart Robson

Gayety: At Piney Ridge, with David Higgins

Montauk: The White Heather

Park (stock): Lost in New York

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

29.                       October 3-8, 1898

Amphion: Carmen, The Masked Ball, Faust, Il Trovatore, with Royal Italian Grand Opera Company

Bijou: Julius Caesar, Hamlet, Macbeth, Othello, with Louis James, Kathryn Kidder, Frederick Warde

Columbia: The Idol’s Eye, with Frank Daniels

Gayety: William H. West’s Big Minstrel Jubilee

Grand Opera House: Natural Gas, with Eddie Girard

Montauk: Bride Elect

Park (stock): Lost in New York

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

30.                       October 10-15, 1898

Amphion: The Meddler, with Stuart Robson

Bijou: Shall We Forgive Her?, East Lynne, with Marie Wainwright

Columbia: The Tree of Knowledge, with James K. Hackett

Gayety: Natural Gas, with Eddie Girard

Grand Opera House: Tempest Tossed

Montauk: A Virginia Courtship, with William H. Crane

Park (stock): Confusion

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

31.                       October 17-22, 1898

Amphion: The Belle of New York, with Dan Daly

Bijou: In Old Kentucky

Columbia: The Serenade, Robin Hood, with the Bostonians

Gayety: Tempest Tossed

Grand Opera House: When Greek Meets Greek, Monte Cristo, with James O’Neill

Montauk: Uncle Dick, with Sol Smith Russell

Park (stock): All the Comforts of Home

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

32.                       October 24-29, 1898

Amphion: War Correspondent!, with Burr McIntosh

Bijou: John Martin’s Secret

Columbia: The Old Homestead, with Denman Thomson

Gayety: When Greek Meets Greek, Monte Cristo, with James O’Neill

Grand Opera House: A Hot Old Time, with Johnny and Emma Ray

Montauk: Cyrano de Bergerac, with Ada Rehan

Park (stock): All the Comforts of Home

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

33.                       October 31-November 5, 1898

Amphion: La Tosca, Antony and Cleopatra, Fedora, with Melbourne MacDowell and Blanche Walsh

Bijou: Cumberland ‘61

Columbia: The Golden Horse Shoe, with the Lilliputians

Gayety: A Hot Old Time, with Johnny and Emma Ray

Grand Opera House: An Irish Gentleman, with Andrew Mack

Montauk: The Fortune Teller, with the Alice Nielson Opera Company

Park (stock): Pink Dominos

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

34.                       November 7-12, 1898

Amphion: A Stranger in New York

Bijou: On Land and Sea

Columbia: A Day and a Night in New York

Gayety: An Irish Gentleman, with Andrew Mack

Grand Opera House: Devil’s Island

Montauk: The Conquerors, with Charles Frohman’s Empire Theatre Company

Park (stock): Everybody’s Friend

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

35.                       November 14-19, 1898

Amphion: The Old Homestead, with Denman Thompson

Bijou: Sweet Inniscarra, with Chauncey Olcott

Columbia: A Brace of Partridges, with Strand Comedy Company

Gayety: Devil’s Island

Grand Opera House: J.H. Haverly’s Minstrels

Montauk: The Conquerors, with Charles Frohman’s Empire Theatre Company

Park (stock): The Long Strike, with J.H. Stoddart

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s (opens September 5), Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

36.                       November 21-26, 1898

Amphion: The Golden Horse Shoe, with the Lilliputians

Bijou: Sweet Inniscarra, with Chauncey Olcott

Brooklyn Academy of Music: The Little Corporal, with Francis Wilson

Columbia: The Christian, with Viola Allen

Gayety: J.H. Haverly’s Minstrels

Grand Opera House: A High Born Lady, with Billy Clifford and Maud Huth

Montauk: The Adventure of Lady Ursula, with E.H. Sothern

Novelty: (recently known as the American; reopens as the Novelty, a former name, November 19) The Lost Paradise

Park (stock): Wolves of New York

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

37.                       November 28-December 3, 1898

Amphion: A Day and a Night in New York, with Otis Harlan

Bijou: On the Wabash

Columbia: Way Down East

Gayety: The Mulligan Guard Ball, with Robert Fitzsimmons and Edward Harrigan

Grand Opera House: A Reign of Error, with the Rogers Brothers

Montauk: The Little Minister, with Maude Adams

Novelty (stock): Lend Me Your Wife

Park (stock company): Wolves of New York

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

38.                       December 5-10, 1898

Amphion: Closed until further notice

Bijou: Going to the Races

Columbia: Way Down East

Gayety: A Reign of Error, with the Rogers Brothers

Grand Opera House: The Mulligan Guard Ball, with Robert Fitzsimmons and Edward Harrigan

Montauk: The Little Minister, with Maude Adams

Novelty (stock): A Fair Rebel

Park (stock): The White Rabbits

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

39.                       December 12-17, 1898

Bijou: When London Sleeps

Columbia: The Jolly Musketeer, with the Jefferson De Angelis Opera Company

Gayety: Devil’s Auction

Grand Opera House: Maids to Order, with the Russell Brothers

Montauk: The Little Minister, with Maude Adams

Novelty (stock): Stock company ends; combination companies hereafter

Park (stock): A Lucky Coon, with Willams and Walker Company

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

40.                       December 19-24, 1898

Bijou: The Silver King, with Carl A. Haswin

Columbia: The Geisha

Gayety: Maids to Order, with the Russell Brothers

Grand Opera House: Devil’s Auction

Montauk: The Royal Box, with Charles Coghlan

Park: Temporarily closed

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

41.                       December 26-31, 1898

Amphion: (reopens) The Tree of Knowledge, Rupert of Hentzau, with James K. Hackett

Bijou: The Finish of Mr. Fresh

Brooklyn Academy of Music: Love Finds the Way, “A Bit of Old Chelsea,” Tess of D’Urbervilles, with Minnie Maddern Fiske

Columbia: Yankee Doodle Dandy, with Edna Wallace Hopper and Thomas Q. Seabrooke

Criterion: (changes back from policy of amateur to professional) The Mascot, with Standard Opera Company

Gayety: What Happened to Jones

Grand Opera House: The Girl from Paris

Montauk: The Liars, with John Drew

Park: (reopens) The Two Orphans, with Kate Claxton

Vaudeville and burlesque: Hyde & Behman’s, Brooklyn Music Hall, Empire, Star

     SUNDAY AMUSEMENT ADVERTISEMENTS IN BROOKLYN DAILY EAGLE 1898


January 24-29, 1898

 

 

Sunday, June 5, 1898

 

Amusement page ads from this point on to late August are omitted. Things began revving up late that month, as seen in this ad from August 28.

 

 

 


No comments:

Post a Comment

17. 1902: MAY-AUGUST

  Grace George (1879-1961), a famous actress often referred to as a “Brooklyn girl,” because she was raised there, although born in Manhat...